Trouble with deliveries

A little over a year ago, when Flippa was one, her previously perfect deliveries started going wrong. After having nicely delivered straight into my hand, or sat in front of me and waited for the “thank you”, she suddenly began braking a metre and a half short of me, putting the dummy down and sometimes giving a little whimper.

I didn’t understand a thing. As far as I know, nothing in particular had happened. What I did get was super frustrated that it wasn’t just a passing thing – it didn’t go away, and at first I couldn’t solve it. Flippa is – as is very common among working cockers – a sensitive soul, even though she can also have great confidence and carry out her tasks with real certainty. But I have to be clear about what I want – not be sloppy with my casting signals so that they can be misread, and be calm and clear in the information I give her. When I am, it runs like clockwork.

But when the deliveries started going wrong I tried to back up, go back to basics, do a warm-up before all retrieving where she got to do easy tasks close to me: touching my hand with no object, taking the dummy out of my hand to walk two metres and deliver into my other hand, and so on. It helped – temporarily. But then we slid back into the problem, maybe not as badly as before, but it wasn’t good enough. I consulted training friends, Lars had a go at training her (because I wanted to see whether it was connected to me, but I got no clear answer on that). I tried to reward better, and what finally untied the knot was that I started rewarding her with a ball quite dramatically. Play generally increases confidence, I find, and she stopped “thinking” so much and just came in at high speed.

I also stopped training the delivery where she sits still in front of me and delivers, completely. I was afraid she would feel some kind of pressure in that situation.

During this period I didn’t train with game at all – that worked even worse. For a while she didn’t even want to grip the game; it seemed to be full of conflict. So I let that training rest. I then discovered that she is good on warm game (very common!) and that the harder the retrieve, the better the delivery. She happily hauls everything home to me and gets to force the terrain. And somewhere around there I started chancing it a bit. Most of the deliveries with warm game were actually good, after all. Or … the majority were good, but she still did one now and then where she put the game down.

My thinking is that to begin with it may have been about some kind of conflict – between us – that I didn’t notice. Maybe I was in a bad mood one day and told her to pull herself together in a slightly irritated voice – as I said, I don’t remember anything, but that’s what I can imagine. Even though I don’t consciously train with aversives, I am a human being with moods; sometimes I am simply grumpy. 😉 AND then perhaps a tiny bit of resource guarding crept into the delivery of game afterwards. When the retrieve is easy, maybe she becomes a bit thoughtful. Should she really give this fine treasure away?

Another thought is that she simply isn’t all that reinforced by retrieving. I am spoiled by Tassla, who loves retrieving and is a seriously brilliant marking dog. Flippa has never been anything like as naturally strong in the retrieving – she wants to hunt.

And maybe it is a bit of each of these? A bit of “I think I’ll keep this one myself”, a bit of “maybe we have a conflict here” and a bit of “here you go, can we get on with hunting now?”.

After putting three birds down at two trials, where Flippa otherwise did almost everything else very nicely in difficult and hot situations, I realised that I can’t chance it. I have to change strategy: she has to learn this properly!

I have now been campaigning game deliveries for a week and a day. I have done around 80 retrieves, between five and 15 a day. I have focused on making it seriously, ridiculously fun. Brisket and bacon as a reward – a reward she gets to chase down in my hand – or throwing the game straight away as a reward. I have focused on SPEED coming in and on the game going all the way into my hand.

For the first five days I trained on the lawn and got her thoroughly wound up in a playful way. Then I started changing the environment; we were on the gravel road, in the meadow, over a stone wall, over a ditch and down into a meadow, over a ditch and up onto the road, short retrieves and long ones. Long ones on stubble field or road, over masses of obstacles like walls and ditches and thickets, out onto stubble and so on.

After a week I could change the environment completely and make use of a group of people. It does seem to become a conflict for her when she has to run towards me and other people (judges, shots and so on) or past other people. The group training went pretty well on the whole – she really has got her speed up now and she is aiming for the hand – but she was in fact a little distracted. You could see it in the way she started taking little loops with the game before she came in. Admittedly she was keen to show it off to the dogs in the group (haha), but after that she seemed to forget a bit what she was doing. The good thing, though, is that she doesn’t leave the game now if she puts it down, but picks it up again fairly quickly.

I filmed the group training, and here is what it looked like:

The trial season for spaniels is incredibly short. It is basically two months in the autumn, with a few scattered trials for a month or so beyond that. (In theory the season runs from 1 October to the end of January, and with luck you can get a rabbit trial in September too, but most of the trials are in October and November.) And I would like to run one more trial this season and try to get that first prize in the open class, so that I can then focus on training for the winners’ class next year. But of course I have to get the retrieving sorted out by then. It may be that this training needs to mature over time, or my brainwashing will work :). If I know myself, I’ll probably drive this training all the way to the wall and try a trial again. 😉 To be continued!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.